I switched back from Rust coreutils to GNU coreutils after upgrading to 26.04; will we be forced to switch back to uutils when we upgrade?

Just wondering what the plan is for 26.10 (and maybe 28.04).

Have you considered asking in the below thread instead?

I doubt the people working on the transition do actually monitor the support and help category here…

2 Likes

aah ok. thought it might be considered “off-topic” haha

I’m exploring something right now, so I’m interested. What made you decide to revert to GNU coreutils?

1 Like

I honestly just trust the GNU version more.

Oh, OK.

Well, it seems that everything is being converted to Rust now precisely because it’s supposedly more secure against bugs, so in time, you’ll have to move over. But I don’t know if anyone can say yet how long that will be.

I am looking again at the question in the topic title.

will we be forced to switch back to uutils when we upgrade?

Online upgrades fail because we have modified the installation in ways that the developers writing the upgrade scripts cannot predict. If the installation has not been switched back to uutils then the upgrade may indeed fail. It may be that the upgrade looks for GNU coreutils and when finding it - upgrades it to rust-coreutils. Maybe not.

No one will force you to upgrade from Ubuntu 26.04 LTS to Ubuntu 28.04 LTS. Take out a Ubuntu Pro subscription and get an extra 5 years Extended Security Maintenance (ESM).

You can stay with the installation you have now. Or, revert to using rust-coreutils and come along for the ride.

Regards

1 Like

I work in research computing in higher ed and we use nfs extensively which isn’t working well with the new rust utils.

What specifically doesn’t work? If other people are experiencing the same problems, it would be worth raising a bug report. If it’s just you, it would be worth looking at what makes your installation different.

1 Like

One report is here.

Thank you. It looks like a genuine bug.

Did you report it (or is there already a bug report)? If not, the devs might not know about it and then it won’t be fixed.

This topic was automatically closed after 30 days. New replies are no longer allowed.