Earlier today, Epic made a blog post with a list of demands from Linux distros in order for them to bring Fortnite to Linux. The post hints they have already contacted maintainers, so I think it would be helpful for users to also illustrate their feeling about Easy Anti Cheat (EAC).
I am sure there will be fair criticism from Linux users who prefer to compile their own kernel, have written custom modules, use a different boot manager, have run-time kernel patching enabled, or don’t feel comfortable with EAC reading and reporting their loaded processes. It’s been some years since I compiled my own kernel, so I will defer to others to better champion these concerns than I can. On my post below, I would like to raise specifically the user consent issues since that is an area EAC is quite bad at and there is a potential of history repeating itself.
EAC has a deeply problematic history with user consent
Some years ago back when I used Windows, I had a negative experience of their Easy Anti Cheat software being installed into the ring0 of my kernel with no user consent involved. I simply launched a game from steam, and foolishly accepted the admin privilege request thinking it was just a DirectX redistributable. I was stunned when I saw the Easy Anti Cheat banner briefly appear and disappear and realized it had installed itself without my consent. (At the time, EAC use was not required to be disclosed on Steam’s store, and Steam does not warn you what dependencies it will be installing when it installs dependencies.) I verified in wireshark that it was sending data to its servers without any agreement from myself. Even worse, uninstalling the game did not uninstall Easy Anti Cheat – and EAC itself did not publish any user facing instructions on how to completely remove it.
These days, I am much more careful about root installs and run Steam as its own user and via flatpak. But I want to make sure I don’t accidentally install EAC, especially if it comes to the official repositories. One of Ubuntu’s strengths is the ease of use it has for end users, and that’s been great for installing Nvidia drivers and such. But I worry about a scenario where I enable some package to install, not realizing it’s EAC because it’s named something that obscures it, like systemd-authenticity or something like that. Or perhaps it really is named ‘systemd-eac’ but I don’t immediately realize that’s Easy Anti Cheat and will result in my process list being reported to Epic Games.
Additional EAC controversies
EAC, for many reasons, is a particularly controversial piece of software. Beyond the reporting of user data, it also has a history of ignoring user consent and it (via Epic) has a minority (40%) ownership stake from a state-run entertainment conglomerate whose state has a heavy surveillance history. (Though in fairness it is worth referencing Wikipedia here that Epic has stated that Tencent does not have access to private data nor provides this to the Chinese government.)
More broadly, there have been controversies with other kernel level anti-cheat software on Windows. A notable one is Genshin Impact’s anticheat being used by ransomware actors. (To my knowledge, EAC itself hasn’t been breached in such a way (yet).)
How should Ubuntu respond?
So this post is a long way of saying I would like to advocate to the Ubuntu team to use maximal caution when dealing with any potential EAC integration or EAC packages.
Likely there will be some end users who want to install EAC and are not concerned about the safety or privacy risks. I’m not arguing to stand in the way of these users or make it unnecessarily difficult for them to make their own choices about their computing. It is their choice how to use their computer.
The key being, users should be reasonably informed before taking such a risk. I think any such EAC package should not be in the main repos, but instead in a third party repository to ensure users really want to install it and aren’t accidentally tricked into it by some package sneaking in a long line of other dependent packages. Given EAC’s past consent-hostile tactics, I think this is a reasonable concern and worth raising.
Thanks for reading!